Christian Field Guide
Practical Faith

What to Do When a Christian Hurts You

Being hurt by a fellow Christian — especially a leader — is one of the most disorienting experiences in the Christian life. Here is what the Bible says about how to handle it, and how to keep your faith intact.

D
Doug Blair
••4 min read
What to Do When a Christian Hurts You

Being hurt by a fellow Christian is one of the most disorienting experiences in the Christian life. It is one thing to be hurt by someone who makes no claim to follow Jesus. It is another thing entirely when the person who wounds you is someone who sits in the same pew, leads the same small group, or stands behind the same pulpit.

If you have been there — or if you are there right now — here is what the Bible says about how to handle it.

Name What Happened

The first step is to be honest about what occurred. Not to catastrophize, not to minimize, but to name it clearly: I was hurt. What happened was wrong. It should not have happened.

Christians sometimes skip this step in the name of grace — they rush to forgiveness before they have honestly acknowledged the wound. That is not grace. It is avoidance. And it tends to produce a kind of brittle, resentful "forgiveness" that is not really forgiveness at all.

Be honest with yourself and with God about what happened and how it affected you.

Follow the Matthew 18 Process

Jesus gives specific instructions for handling conflict within the church in Matthew 18:15-17:

  1. Go to the person privately and tell them what they did.
  2. If they do not listen, bring one or two others with you.
  3. If they still do not listen, bring it before the church.

This process is not optional, and it is not primarily about getting an apology. It is about giving the other person the opportunity to repent and be restored — and about protecting the community from unaddressed sin.

Many Christians skip step one and go straight to talking to everyone else about what happened. That is gossip, not conflict resolution. It feels satisfying in the short term and produces bitterness in the long term.

Go to the person. It is hard. It is worth it.

Forgive — But Understand What Forgiveness Is

Forgiveness is not the same as reconciliation. Forgiveness is a decision you make — to release the debt, to stop holding the wrong against the person, to refuse to let bitterness take root. It is something you do for your own sake as much as for theirs.

Reconciliation is a restored relationship — and it requires repentance from the person who wronged you. You can forgive someone who never apologizes. You cannot reconcile with someone who refuses to acknowledge what they did.

Forgiveness does not mean pretending the harm did not happen. It does not mean trusting the person again immediately. It does not mean staying in a relationship that is unsafe. It means releasing the debt and leaving justice in God's hands.

Do Not Let One Person's Failure Become a Reason to Abandon the Faith

This is the most important thing to say. When a Christian — especially a leader — fails you, the temptation is to conclude that Christianity itself is false, or that the church is not worth belonging to.

That conclusion does not follow. Christians are sinners saved by grace — not perfect people. The church is a community of people in the process of being transformed, not a community of people who have already arrived. When a Christian fails, it is evidence that Christians are sinners. It is not evidence that Jesus is not who he claimed to be.

The failure of a person who claims to follow Jesus is not a refutation of Jesus. It may be a refutation of that person's claim — or it may be evidence of the ongoing reality of sin in people who are genuinely trying to follow him.

Do not let someone else's failure become the reason you walk away from the one who has never failed you.

Get Help

If you have been seriously hurt — especially by a leader, or in a situation involving abuse — do not try to handle it alone. Talk to a trusted pastor, a counselor, or a mature Christian friend. Some situations require outside help, and seeking it is not weakness. It is wisdom.

The church has failed many people. That is a tragedy. But the answer to the church's failure is not to abandon the church. It is to find a healthier expression of it — and to keep your eyes on Jesus, who is the same yesterday, today, and forever, regardless of what his followers do.

D

Written by

Doug Blair

Doug Blair is the author of the Christian Field Guide series — scripture-anchored reference tools for everyday believers navigating faith conversations.

Go deeper

Equip yourself with the full series

The Christian Field Guide series gives every believer — from new Christians to seasoned students — the scripture-anchored reference tools to understand and discuss the faith with confidence.

Enjoying this? We explore questions like this on Facebook three times a week. Follow the Christian Field Guide.

Follow Us on Facebook